[rescue] Top vs. Bottom posting (was: revived: TiBook G4 867...)

Lionel Peterson lionel4287 at gmail.com
Fri Apr 13 12:00:38 CDT 2018


> On Apr 13, 2018, at 11:46 AM, John Floren <john at jfloren.net> wrote:
>
> One might ask if it was worth the edit to go through and snip and
> in-line reply when the in-line replies are primarily "me too".

I find neither of my two previous responses to this email, one top-posted, the
other bottom-posted, 'insulting':

Because I chose to trim my response first, either tip or bottom-posting fully
displays in one window with no need for scrolling in any reasonable desktop
mail client - you simply start reading where there is no indentation.

On a portable (phone) the entire message may or may not display on a single,
no scroll, window, so top posting seems appropriate for that audience.

On auxiliary displays (iWatch) top-posting is a clear winner.

I'll top-post, but I'm aware that may limit my audience, rub some people wrong
- as the man once said 'you can't please everyone so you've got to please
yourself." [0]

Lionel


More information about the rescue mailing list