[geeks] 32 Gig 1.6" SCA drives......

Kurt Mosiejczuk kurt at csh.rit.edu
Thu May 2 23:26:01 CDT 2002


On Thu, 2 May 2002, Sridhar the POWERful wrote:

> > in the last year, I have had a 100% failure rate on IBM Deskstar
> > drives :( one local distributor no longer stocks IBM drives, cause
> > they had a 90 to 95% return rate in the first 12 months on IBM drives
> > :(

> That's what you get for using IDE.  I haven't had a *single* problem with
> an Ultrastar.

To be fair to him though, for quite a while IBMs IDE drives were as
solid as their SCSI.  Apparently someone decided IDE meant cheap and
started cutting the wrong corners.

It's those sudden complete changes in quality that make you question
ALL IBM drives...  I haven't seen any problem with any of my
Ultrastars, but I'd be a little wary of buying a brand new model
IBM drive...

--Kurt



More information about the geeks mailing list